You can also read this news on BH NEWS: Cardano Delegates Reject Toto Finance’s $3.3 Million Copper Plan Delegates in the Cardano ecosystem, known as DReps, have vetoed a proposal by Toto Fin
You can also read this news on BH NEWS: Cardano Delegates Reject Toto Finance’s $3.3 Million Copper Plan
Delegates in the Cardano ecosystem, known as DReps, have vetoed a proposal by Toto Finance to withdraw 22 million ADA from the treasury for a Strategic Copper Reserve. Representing 2.86 billion ADA, the delegates voted against the initiative, while those in favor accounted for just 20.02 million ADA. The vote concluded on November 15.
Risk Exposure and Fee Structure Drive Rejection
Among those opposing the proposal was John MacPherson, a DRep who clarified that his decision was not a rejection of tokenizing real-world assets on Cardano. Instead, MacPherson argued that the proposal unnecessarily exposed the treasury to fluctuations in both copper and ADA prices.
John MacPherson noted, “The proposal articulates its risks more clearly than most initiatives, but it’s not appropriate for the treasury to simultaneously bear the price risks of both copper and ADA.”
Further compounding the criticism, Toto Finance’s proposed structure would allow them to collect up to 3.4 million ADA in fees, escalating concerns over the plan’s financial layout.
Toto Finance’s Copper Acquisition and Token Issuance Plan
Led by Monty Metzger, Toto Finance unveiled their strategy on October 15. The plan aimed to use 14.72 million ADA to purchase copper, storing it in a warehouse near New Orleans. The company intended to issue a CuTT token for each pound of copper held, with a selling timeline of 18-24 months.
On Monday, with ADA trading at $0.152, the proposed 22 million ADA was valued at approximately $3.3 million. The proposal stirred controversy due to its demand for the Cardano treasury to directly finance a commodity position.
Cardano Foundation Votes Against Proposal
The Cardano Foundation, acting as a DRep, also voted against the proposal in October. While acknowledging the potential of real-world asset tokenization, the Foundation opposed handing over 22 million ADA to a single entity without adequate safeguarding measures. Known for supporting the Cardano ecosystem’s development and governance, the Foundation highlighted the proposal’s excessive fee burden and lack of necessary security protocols.
The Cardano Foundation stated, “The proposal incurs high fees and finances a concentrated commodity position without the necessary safety measures.”
Three of the seven members of the Constitutional Committee also voted against the proposal, with the other four abstaining. This coalition indicated insufficient support for the proposal not only among DReps but across various governance layers.
Cryptocurrency commentator Ingeniero Cripto echoed MacPherson’s stance, pointing out that the critical issue lay in exposing the Cardano treasury to copper prices in addition to ADA. While appreciating the value of RWA projects on Cardano, Ingeniero Cripto distinguished between directly financing assets and building infrastructure for them.
Continue Reading:
Cardano Delegates Reject Toto Finance’s $3.3 Million Copper Plan